There should be Open Records Across the Board Including the Name of the Accuser

House approves CPS bills
Measures would require child-protection agency to release records
Amanda J. Crawford
The Arizona Republic
Mar. 20, 2008 12:00 AM

Child Protective Services is the state agency charged with protecting Arizona’s children, but exactly what they do in most cases – even those in which the child has died from abuse – has remained largely hidden from public view.

A bill approved by the Arizona House of Representatives on Wednesday would change that. It would require the agency to release records when a child is killed or seriously injured from abuse or neglect, unless the prosecutor determines this would cause material harm to an investigation.

House Bill 2454, which now goes to the Senate, is part of a package of reforms introduced in the wake of legislative hearings in the fall on the deaths of three Tucson children whose families were involved with CPS. Other bills approved by the House this week would make state employees’ disciplinary records open to public inspection and open some court hearings on custody decisions to the public.

Rep. Jonathan Paton, R-Tucson, said he believes public scrutiny will help make meaningful reforms at the child-welfare agency.

“Our whole principle of government is checks and balances, and the ultimate check and balance is for the people to know what is going on,” said Paton, sponsor of HB 2454. “And the one thing this agency has been missing is real public scrutiny.”

David Bodney, an attorney at Steptoe & Johnson who represents The Arizona Republic, said there has long been a “culture of secrecy” at CPS: The agency usually argues that one law or another prevents them from releasing even basic information on cases to the public and media. Current law allows the agency to release summaries in cases of child death or near-fatality. But Bodney said those summaries are “practically useless” with information that is either inadequate or sometimes misleading.

Last year, The Republic and the Arizona Daily Star sued CPS for information on the deaths of three young Tucson children, Brandon Williams and Ariana and Tyler Payne, who died after CPS investigated allegations of abuse.

The newspapers won, which allowed the legislative hearings on the children’s deaths to be open to the public and the media.

Rep. Kirk Adams, who chaired the hearings in his government committee and sponsored some of the CPS reform bills, said those hearings and the media coverage of the deaths led to the House passing two other reform bills to address problems found in those cases. One requires CPS to follow custody orders, which didn’t happen in the Payne case, when the kids were placed with their father, now accused in their murder. The other requires CPS to notify law enforcement when a child is missing, something that Adams has said might have saved 5-year-old Brandon Williams.

“I, in my office, witnessed the power of public records in affecting the public good,” Adams said on the House floor.

Adams and Paton worked with officials from CPS, the Governor’s Office, other lawmakers and stakeholders in crafting the reform package.

Some Democratic lawmakers and the Governor’s Office have expressed concerns about one piece of HB 2454 that allows the agency to challenge a prosecutor’s decision not to release information. Other provisions allow the public or media to challenge any decision not to release records.

Mike Haener, a deputy chief of staff to Gov. Janet Napolitano, said the governor worries that including the agency in that part of the bill could set up an adversarial relationship with prosecutors, whom it should be working with cooperatively. The governor is otherwise supportive of the proposal, he said.

But others say they worry that releasing information on children’s deaths could harm other family members. Rep. Pete Rios, D-Hayden, called the bill a “bad piece of legislation” that has the potential to “re-victimize” other children, especially in rural areas.

“The concerns that I have is that we open CPS records and we provide information, but even if we cross out names . . . people are still going to know who we are talking about,” he said. “They are going to know the victims, the siblings, other people in the household that may have been physically abused, sexually abused. . . . I don’t want to re-victimize the victims.”

About yvonnemason

Background:  The eldest of five children, Yvonne was born May 17, 1951 in Atlanta, Georgia. Raised in East Point, Georgia, she moved to Jackson County, Ga. until 2006 then moved to Port St. Lucie, Florida where she currently makes her home.  Licensed bounty hunter for the state of Georgia. Education:  After a 34 year absence, returned to college in 2004. Graduated with honors in Criminal Justice with an Associate’s degree from Lanier Technical College in 2006. Awards:  Nominated for the prestigious GOAL award in 2005 which encompasses all of the technical colleges. This award is based not only on excellence in academics but also leadership, positive attitude and the willingness to excel in one’s major. Affiliations:  Beta Sigma Phi Sorority  Member of The Florida Writer’s Association – Group Leader for St Lucie County The Dream:  Since learning to write at the age of five, Yvonne has wanted to be an author. She wrote her first novel Stan’s Story beginning in 1974 and completed it in 2006. Publication seemed impossible as rejections grew to 10 years. Determined, she continued adding to the story until her dream came true in 2006. The Inspiration:  Yvonne’s brother Stan has been her inspiration and hero in every facet of her life. He was stricken with Encephalitis at the tender age of nine months. He has defied every roadblock placed in his way and has been the driving force in every one of her accomplishments. He is the one who taught her never to give up The Author: Yvonne is currently the author of several novels, including:  Stan’s Story- the true story of her brother’s accomplishments, it has been compared to the style of Capote, and is currently being rewritten with new information for re-release.  Tangled Minds - a riveting story about a young girl’s bad decision and how it taints everyone’s life around her yet still manages to show that hope is always possible. This novel has been compared to the writing of Steinbeck and is currently being written as a screenplay. This novel will be re-released by Kerlak Publishing in 2009  Brilliant Insanity – released by Kerlak Publishing October 2008  Silent Scream – Released by October 2008- Slated to be made into a movie Yvonne’s Philosophy in Life - “Pay it Forward”: “In this life we all have been helped by others to attain our dreams and goals. We cannot pay it back but what we can do is ‘pay it forward’. It is a simple
This entry was posted in Abuse by CPS, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to There should be Open Records Across the Board Including the Name of the Accuser

  1. TSwain says:

    what a great site and informative posts, I will add a backlink and bookmark your site. Keep up the good work!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s